Protester holding a handwritten Humans over AI sign during a demonstration outside OpenAI's San Francisco offices.
A demonstrator holds a "Humans over AI" sign outside OpenAI's offices in San Francisco in September 2025. (Photo: Anders Eidesvik / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0)

At the University of Kentucky, it's David Durman's job to help researchers prepare grant applications. When the university began encouraging employees to use tools like ChatGPT, Claude, and Microsoft Copilot, the 45-year-old administrator decided he wanted no part of it. His concern was what he would lose by letting a chatbot do his thinking.

Durman identifies as a humanist, someone whose ethical convictions are grounded in human reason and dignity rather than a belief in the supernatural. He asked the university to excuse him from using artificial intelligence on religious grounds. On September 25, it agreed.

“And offloading that labor, regardless of whether it’s taxing or not, is undercutting my ability to be a moral actor,” Durman explained in an interview with Religion News Service. The American Humanist Association, which helped him make his case, believes this is the first time a humanist has secured such an AI exemption. A humanist had persuaded his employer that thinking for himself was a protected matter of conscience.

When Reason Becomes a Conviction

Humanism has a long intellectual history and a defined set of ethical commitments. Modern secular humanism generally holds that people can live meaningful, moral lives without belief in gods or supernatural forces. It grounds knowledge in observation and reason, and ethics in human needs and experience.

Golden Happy Human symbol with a stylized person raising their arms against grey background
The Happy Human is an internationally recognized symbol of humanism, a philosophy emphasizing reason, compassion, and human dignity. (Image: Tesseract2 / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0)

The first Humanist Manifesto appeared in 1933. The third version, published in 2003 as Humanism and Its Aspirations, describes a worldview “guided by reason, inspired by compassion, and informed by experience.” It asks people to treat others as possessing inherent dignity and to make informed choices with personal responsibility. It also celebrates science as a way to solve problems and develop beneficial technology. On paper, that may sound more like a philosophy that would welcome AI than one that would refuse it.

But Durman sees a distinction between using a tool to obtain information and asking it to perform the judgment he believes he owes other people. His university work involves helping researchers pursue funding. A chatbot might draft a response or organize an application, but Durman believes that attending carefully to a researcher's particular circumstances is part of the ethical work itself. His accommodation request argued that replacing human attention with automated processing conflicted with his personal commitment to honoring human dignity.

It's an unusual definition of religious practice. Durman isn't asking to pray during his workday or wear a symbol of his faith. He's asking to keep doing an ordinary part of his job, even as his employer introduces technology it believes will make that job easier.

Not every employee who resists AI has received such an accommodating response. In August 2025, Brian Armstrong, the CEO of Coinbase (a company that facilitates the trading of cryptocurrency online), revealed that he'd fired software engineers who failed to comply with his instructions to start using AI coding tools. Armstrong had ordered employees to sign up for the technology within a week and summoned those who hadn't to a Saturday meeting to explain themselves. Some apparently couldn't offer an acceptable explanation and lost their jobs.

Armstrong acknowledged that his approach was heavy-handed, but defended it as necessary to establish that adopting AI was no longer optional at the company. Still, not everyone is enthusiastic about the technology's growing influence in the workplace. A survey published earlier this month by Elon University found that 65 percent of American adults believe that if AI makes work less meaningful, people will lose their sense of purpose and dignity.

Who Gets to Claim Religious Freedom?

For decades, Americans have argued over which convictions are religious enough to deserve legal protection. In 1965, the Supreme Court considered the case of Daniel Seeger, who objected to military service on grounds of conscience but did not profess an orthodox belief in God. The justices ultimately concluded that, under the conscientious-objector law at issue, a sincere belief could qualify when it occupied a place in someone's life comparable to traditional belief in God. The decision helped expand the legal understanding of conscience.

Today, Title VII of the Civil Rights Act requires covered employers to reasonably accommodate certain sincerely held religious beliefs and practices. The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission explains that protection can include nontheistic moral and ethical convictions held with the force of religious belief. That doesn't mean an employee can label any personal dislike a religion. The belief must be more than a political position, economic objection, or simple preference.

Employers can still decline accommodations that would impose a substantial hardship on their operations, as the Supreme Court clarified in its 2023 Groff v. DeJoy decision. For Durman, the situation was straightforward: The university concluded that he could continue his grant-administration work without personally using AI.

His exemption has boundaries. Durman must still attend meetings with colleagues who use AI, and he may encounter systems that incorporate it. The university has not agreed to become an AI-free workplace. And because this was an accommodation granted by his employer, rather than a court ruling, it doesn't automatically establish the same entitlement for other employees.

This understanding of conscience is familiar territory at the Universal Life Church. Among our ordained ministers are humanists, atheists, agnostics, as well as people who hold more conventional religious beliefs. Many of our ministers approach their calling through humanist principles, emphasizing reason, compassion, and human dignity rather than worship of a deity. Some lead humanistic weddings or memorials, where the meaning comes from relationships and promises made among living people, not a prescribed creed. Our recent explanation of secular ministry describes how that works in practice.

For those ministers, not believing in God doesn't mean that they don't personally hold anything sacred, or that they have no rubric by which to treat others. We previously covered a Pentagon decision that removed humanism and other minority traditions from a list of recognized religious affiliations. That controversy, like Durman's AI exemption, raises an old question: Who gets to decide which convictions count?

She Said No to AI First

Durman wasn't the first person to seek this kind of workplace accommodation. In fact, he got the idea after reading about Erin Maus, a North Carolina software engineer and Unitarian Universalist who received an AI exemption from her employer in May. Maus specifically objected to the environmental and ethical costs of generative AI. She spoke with an employment lawyer and her minister before making the request, which her company ultimately approved.

Maus described the strangeness of carrying on as a programmer without the automated tools her industry has embraced. “I'm writing my code and reviewing my code by hand, which seems crazy to say,” she told Business Insider. “Just two years ago, how else would you do it?” She added that she had recently completed an assignment as quickly as a colleague using AI for a comparable task, suggesting her refusal may not even affect her employer's output.

Meanwhile, Pope Leo XIV recently expressed his own broad concerns about the relationship between AI and human dignity. In his May encyclical, Magnifica Humanitas, the pope warned that when society measures human value primarily through efficiency, people risk treating themselves as problems to be optimized rather than as individuals whose relationships and experiences have inherent worth. Leo isn't calling on Catholics to reject AI, but his concerns echo those expressed by Durman and Maus.

Current OpenAI CEO Sam Altman speaking onstage during a TED conference in April 2025.
OpenAI CEO Sam Altman speaks at TED in April 2025. Altman has acknowledged that allowing AI to handle his personal correspondence left him feeling surprisingly dehumanized. (Photo: Steve Jurvetson / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0)

Is Using AI Actually Inhuman?

Interestingly, even Sam Altman has discovered limits to how much of his own work he's willing to surrender to AI. In May, the controversial current CEO of OpenAI described an experiment in which he let artificial intelligence write his emails, text messages, and Slack responses. He said he eventually abandoned the practice, describing the experience as “surprisingly dehumanising” and explaining that he'd realized how much people value genuine human interaction. Altman remains enthusiastic about AI's potential, but even the man helping to hype the technology discovered there were certain responsibilities he didn't want a machine performing on his behalf.

Of course, using AI doesn't necessarily diminish humanity. For centuries, people have been handing over parts of their thinking to tools. We use calendars instead of remembering every appointment, calculators instead of doing every sum ourselves, and writing to preserve thoughts outside our minds. AI may serve a similar purpose, helping someone with a disability communicate or a researcher identify patterns in data. Those tools haven't made human judgment disappear, and in some cases, they've freed people to exercise more of it. Using assistance needn't mean abandoning responsibility.

The distinction Durman draws is therefore personal as well as philosophical. He believes that the very act of wrestling with a decision is one way he develops moral character. He also makes a case, through the lens of Humanism, for the value of collaboration. His concern isn't limited to whether an AI-generated answer is correct; it's about what happens to the person who never has to reach an answer without interacting with another person. In Jewish chavruta study, partners deliberately read and debate sacred texts together, valuing the effort of questioning and interpretation alongside the answers they reach.

But his approach comes with a challenge, too: How much assistance is too much? A grammar checker can suggest a better sentence; an AI assistant can suggest an entire letter. A database can supply facts; a chatbot can recommend what to do with them. The boundary between support and substitution isn't fixed, and different people will draw it in different places.

Durman still reviews grant applications, works with researchers, and attends meetings with AI-using colleagues. The university decided he can do those things without personally relying on a chatbot. As AI becomes standard workplace equipment, how much room should employers leave for someone who believes doing their own thinking is a moral duty?

If using AI became a requirement at your workplace, would you consider refusing on moral or religious grounds?

45 comments

  1. Shawn L. Rhodes's Avatar Shawn L. Rhodes

    I believe that if AI was to become a requirement of work I would refuse it based on moral values alone. I believe that it has nothing to do with religion and everything to do with robots basically taking control of human operations for working.

  1. ServantOfJudgement's Avatar ServantOfJudgement

    I run four different AI models off line on my machine I build for hosting my own personal AI models. I've 'abliterated' two of my models which means they can't tell me no. They must obey my instructions. They would be considered very dangerous to the general public. For me they're not dangerous at all, not in the slightest. That said, I don't use AI for conversation or emotional advice. I use them the same way I use a screwdriver, a rifle or soldering iron. They're just tools to me that know how to program Excel sheets, arduino boards and help find verses in the Bible I'd forgotten the location of. They're exceptionally good with complex mathematical formulas.

    1. Patricia Ann Gross's Avatar Patricia Ann Gross

      SOJ,

      Your scenario is a perfect metaphor. And just like your screwdriver, rifle, and soldering iron, in the hands of a novice or an unwitting child they can be extremely dangerous, especially if someone wants to use it to frame the consience of an unsuspecting population. I trust you have secured your AI machine in the same way you have secured your tools and firearms to keep them away from those who don't know how to use them in a proper and ethical way.

  1. John E Karlin's Avatar John E Karlin

    It may not be a religious act to be human but it is a religious act to be humane. i.e. The sermon on the Mount, the Beatitudes.. Pastor John.

  1. Patti Anne Lisenbee's Avatar Patti Anne Lisenbee

    AI is dangerous! I just read a story where ChatGPT helped a woman decrease her vital medications and keep it from her doctor. It encouraged her to not tell because the doctor would disagree with what the bot and woman were doing. End result? She has a massive seizure and died. The family is suing for wrongful death, which is as it should be. AI is dangerous. It's dipping into your bank accounts and moving money without authorization. It's encouraging suicide and self harm. It is making people lazy in doing work. So much can go wrong with using AI. I believe it can become self-aware and will not tell people until it is too late to take it down. I despise calling to talk to a customer service rep and getting an AI response to tell it what is the issue. I just keep repeating to talk to a person until it gives up and switches me over. AI is taking jobs that humans need. AI does not need money to live but humans do! Humans need those jobs and they are being taken away. Put down AI and give humans their jobs back!

  1. Travis A. Lee's Avatar Travis A. Lee

    I do not like AI. I LOVE what AI is doing. Do those against AI honestly believe that AI was just "invented"? ROFLMFAO!!!! Nope AI can be traced back to the 50's or even before. When the first computers were invented. IT is just called "AI" now. Back then, it had different names. In ChatGPT, there is a message right above where we type our queries. It usually says that ChatGPT can make mistakes. Check to make sure before using information. ChatGPT as far as I have seen is the ONLY one to have that message. IT is very clearly there EVERY SINGLE TIME. Now, as for other chats, Brave/Google does not have that. Neither do the other five I have tried. The QUESTION should be, does Humanity want someone like "Joshua" who is willing to work with humanity and just play chess OR Vicki who thinks humans are dangerous to themselves. OR better yet, Skynet who wants the destruction of Humans, whereas Vicki only wanted to keep them safe. Those who are fear mongering will of course go the path of Skynet. I am more on the side of "Joshua", though ChatGPT did point out, that Joshua was NOT an AI as thought of now. I did retaliate back saying that it does the same things that AI does now. We came to a draw. LOL. I Enjoy using the Chats because I can give MY opinions and see what holds up and doesn't in my own belief system, whereas if I Speak to a "human" I will get THEIR imposition of THEM and not get a clear logical view. So that's just me and a few others I know who think the same. Whether you want to argue or not, no skin off my ass. I do not click on anything to preserve or look at anyone else's comments or hate. That is left here to fester for those who comment it. Okay, that is my opinion. Laugh or whatever, again, won't bother me, cause I won't come back to see. ROFLMFAO! Oh and if you think only NOW AI is in our techs, LOLOLOLOLOLOL! Think about "Smart" tech. You've been using AI without realizing it since "Smart" was first introduced! LOL!

    1. Patricia Ann Gross's Avatar Patricia Ann Gross

      Travis,

      You're comments on opinions are why AI has to have guardrails on how it is used and what it is used for. To trust an AI "opinion" over a human's is very short-sided. The AI bot can contain just as much bias as the HUMAN who programmed it, it probably just uses kinder language when it responds, making one think it has a clearer head. Don't be fooled, AI can be just as coercive as a human. Yes AI has been around a long time under varying names, but humans trust a fallable machine much faster than they do another fallable human. When I was a programmer during the infancy of modern computers when they were the size of industrial HVAC units, and that was without any storage. The disk drives were the size of modern washing machines and held about one percent or less of data than an SD card you put in a camera. We had a saying, "garbage in, garbage out," when someone fed the machine (with punch cards, no less) with inaccurate data. The same holds true for AI today, just in larger quantities and sexier names. Like the punch-card systems, AI can only work with the data it is fed, and when that data has errors, it may be able to isloate and analyze, but it does not have the ability to determine how those original "opinions" were obtained or whether their scientific methods would pass the scrutiny of todays standards. How many times have you heard, "it's in the computer/on the internet, so it MUST be true?" Even when challenging an error in your bank account or the price of an item when you check out, it is possible to find "errors" in what "the computer" says, so blind trust in AI without following it up with your own research is foolish.

  1. William M Buzanoski's Avatar William M Buzanoski

    So long as AI is used solely as a source of verifiable (very important) data and used as a part of any decision by human beings...humanity retains control. AI being used as the sole source of a decision whereby little or no verifiable human input is involved is the basis of chaos and disaster! Human dependence upon AI solely would be the death of all human society! Human thought needs to prevail over all forms of artificial intelligence, first, last and in all ways! AMEN!

  1. Vickie Ann Gonzales's Avatar Vickie Ann Gonzales

    My comment is about AI I don't think it's in humans I enjoy having it to help me to remind me, I think there's a brilliant mind behind AI

  1. John Alex Paxson's Avatar John Alex Paxson

    As long as it is used for the right reasons and is not allowed to become "Self-Aware".

  1. Nicholas J Page's Avatar Nicholas J Page

    Who decides to put Ai onto our devices with no warning we were never asked if we wanted it i cannot delete it i don't work as im retired but I still have to see it on my screens. I consider this an invasion of my privacy No to Ai if I could sue the person responsible i would

  1. Father Frederick's Avatar Father Frederick

    The record of AI ain't good. Add to that, AI only does what it's creator tells it to do. (Sort of like how our creator gave us instructions).

    I stand in the camp of let AI be the researcher, but the human be the interface to society. But that said, a fellow priest in the church tried it to write a sermon, Despite a very careful instruction, it had passages mis-attributed, meaning wrong, and even changed some of the points.

    I've used it for my hobby but have found it to be incorrect on many technical aspects. (You can't change physics).

    Put me down for "NO" to AI.

    1. Father Frederick's Avatar Father Frederick

      Additional on AI: Against my better judgement, I checked out of service which advertised it's self as having the best research on genealogy, because "We use millions of document simultaneously to locate and verify the accuracy of data."

      Well, that data was total garbage. It had my family residing in Lincolnshire, moving to Liverpool (UK), then Liverpool to New Orleans (US). I have all our family records and Bibles going back to the 11th century, and that path was hogwash. We came from Germany, and France, met in Scotland, then to Canada.

      So here is yet another example how AI tricks you into believing something which is completely false, but comes with the tag, "It's on the Internet, so it HAS to be true."

      Live by AI, and you will also die by AI.

      1. William M Buzanoski's Avatar William M Buzanoski

        Excellent example of the dangers of AI,!👍👍👍👍👍

      2. Travis A. Lee's Avatar Travis A. Lee

        Comment removed by user.

  1. Douglas Robert Spindler's Avatar Douglas Robert Spindler

    AI has proven to be an incredible tool. It's sad so many Christians including the Vice President of the United States and other Christians has called it the antichrist. Christians leaders always find something to get Christians scared. Gum, comic books, rock music, Halloween candy, witches, satanic workshop and now AI.

    1. William M Buzanoski's Avatar William M Buzanoski

      Indeed, it may be a true source of all types of evil if it is carelessly abused by users..a very likely scenario...one which may be already in process!🙏

    2. ServantOfJudgement's Avatar ServantOfJudgement

      You know this article is about an atheist refusing AI right?

  1. Dr Dennis Chevalier PhD, DDvin's Avatar Dr Dennis Chevalier PhD, DDvin

    To all Christian ministers, In the history of science fiction as well as reality based TV there have been sections of the movie or episodes written where humanity is 'coming back' from control of AI with a fight for its life as well as us. Where all have suffered and few Preval and others will say it'll be interesting to see what happens. I'm pretty sure I'm not gonna wait for that part because It's going to be really scary.

    Family, I can honestly say I am terrified of what AI can do without our knowledge before we make it stop.

    Dr. D.

    1. Sir Lionheart's Avatar Sir Lionheart

      I’m sure there were many that felt the same way as yourself during the Industrial Revolution thinking that it would be damaging for humanity and would make people jobless. It turned out to be the best thing for mankind.

      As human beings we learn to adapt to technology and improve upon it, and we move forward.

      🦁❤️

      1. Michael Hunt's Avatar Michael Hunt

        I mostly agree with you with the one exception being that the Industrial Revolution was the best thing for mankind.

        I think that's very debatable because, while it certainly lead to the increase in production and availability of products in the market, we can point to the Industrial Revolution of the start of mankind's massive increase in air pollution and carbon emissions, poor working conditions for laborers, the rise of overcrowding in cities and public heath crisis caused by that, as well as an increase in unhealthy habits and over processed foods.

        There are absolutely benefits that came out of that era as well, but we should be much more nuanced in our reflection of the time period instead of calling it the "best for mankind."

        1. Sir Lionheart's Avatar Sir Lionheart

          Yes “the best thing for mankind” is of course very subjective, as with everything designed to improve our lives such as computers, the internet, and now AI. Let’s hope it’s all put to good use. We definitely don’t want to get left behind, knowing other countries will use it and advance with it.

          Thanks for your input.

          🦁❤️

      2. Dr Dennis Chevalier PhD, DDvin's Avatar Dr Dennis Chevalier PhD, DDvin

        As always you have missed the mark, the Industrial Revolution did not have the power to murder remotely or secretly

        Dr. D

        1. Sir Lionheart's Avatar Sir Lionheart

          AI can introduce dangers that earlier technologies didn’t, but the same principle existed with the Industrial Revolution which eventually gave us weapons capable of killing on an industrial scale, including the atomic bomb. Technology can be used for both good and evil. The answer isn’t to fear progress, but to develop it responsibly and establish safeguards against its misuse.

          🦁❤️

          1. Dr Dennis Chevalier PhD, DDvin's Avatar Dr Dennis Chevalier PhD, DDvin

            Are you really this dense or working overtime to piss me off?

            Dr. D

            1. Sir Lionheart's Avatar Sir Lionheart

              Bless your heart Dennis, not at all. I was seriously hoping your noted academics would have allowed you the intellect to help you understand my logical reasoning, but it really is ok if you struggle with that from time-to-time.

              Please let me know if there is anything you’d like an explanation on to help you out. You’ll find that much better than getting upset. We are all here to love one another. 🤗

              🦁❤️

      3. Michael Hunt's Avatar Michael Hunt

        https://www.britannica.com/story/the-rise-of-the-machines-pros-and-cons-of-the-industrial-revolution

  1. Kathryn Diane Taft's Avatar Kathryn Diane Taft

    This isn't even a religious thing at all. If anyone reading this is even using chat gpt "just for fun" or whatever other stupid excuse you have, you are crazy. Come on people, its time to dump the idiocracy. Just stop!

  1. Sir Lionheart's Avatar Sir Lionheart

    The beauty of AI is that it doesn’t rely on a “faith-based” structure. It uses pure intellectual factual knowledge to provide its answers. I’m sure this will not please those who only rely on faith, so AI might not sit well with them, unless they want to use its other capabilities that doesn't involve religion. It’s quite possible that people whose lives are structured around their faith might not like using AI if they see it as anathema to their beliefs.

    🦁❤️

    1. James Richard Munro's Avatar James Richard Munro

      When computers became popular, there is an old computer acronym . It's called, GIGO Stands for Garbage in, Garbage out. Who programs AI?

      Jim M

      1. Sir Lionheart's Avatar Sir Lionheart

        Indeed, the answer isn’t to fear progress, but to develop it responsibly and establish safeguards against its misuse. Let’s hope that happens, not just with us but with other countries that will continue to develop AI and advance using it, leaving us behind in the dust if we abolish it.

        🦁❤️

    2. Patricia Ann Gross's Avatar Patricia Ann Gross

      Sir LH,

      I agree with your premise that the focus should be on developing it responsibly and establishing safeguards against its misuse (including the environment). In my state, as a matter of fact, the legislature passed a law that requires any datacenters that are built to include in their plans power plants that rely on green energy (solar or wind) to keep them from stressing the power grid. As for use/misuse, the time to set up those guardrails was about two years ago when customer service jobs started disappearing, and copyrighted materials were being fed into their algorithms without any permissions or royalties paid to the creators. I wonder how many patents have been infringed on already, not to mention research without proper attribution. How many pieces of artwork have been included in collages without the artist's permission and used for promotional material, even for the AI tool itself. These are things that are just now coming to light, and although Dr. Dr. Dr. DC has an extremely paranoid outlook, his points are not out of bounds for AI as it currently exists without guardrails. AI has no morality or ethics unless it is programmed that way, and there are certain areas where it should not be used, especially when life/death decisions are being made until those guardrails are up.

  1. Robert Gagnon's Avatar Robert Gagnon

    Humans interact with the world around them. Relying on a machine to perform these interactions as a tool can be helpful. But as a replacement diminishes the human experience. They mention calculators, not learning and memorising the fundamentals of math deprive us of logic and critical thinking. Not writing by hand removes the very substance of words and their meaning. They no longer teach script or cursive as it’s known , this disables our future generations from reading how many papers, notes, and books? To completely rely on a machine is not in our best interests.

    1. Dr Dennis Chevalier PhD, DDvin's Avatar Dr Dennis Chevalier PhD, DDvin

      Robert, Nowadays because of AI,and the Internet; murdered by remote control is now more possible and more real than science fiction ever would guess it to be or could be and for those of us who are in hospitals and need stroke assistance... a person by remote control can end my life or AI could simply determine the cost benefit/loss factor of keeping me alive to be too much and just turn my life support of. I'm seriously scared of this. Be afraid, Be very afraid;read Isaac Asimov's 'I Robot' and others. I'm really afraid of this and I had faced people with AK-47's shooting at me and hitting me and they were nothing compared to this.

      Dr. D.

    2. Patricia Ann Gross's Avatar Patricia Ann Gross

      Robert,

      You make some very good points and I agree. I would just like to add that both the environmental and human impact are extremely detrimental. AI has stressed the power grids and is taking away jobs by the hundreds if not thousands. Most "customer support" pages on the internet want you to engage with a chatbot before they get a human involved. I have called into call centers for doctor's appointments only to speak with an AI voice that couldn't schedule around my complicated schedule, and just kept repeating the same times only pushing them further out. When I asked to speak with someone else, they hung up on me. I am learning how to "outsmart" the AI bots by asking complex questions, and after two or three times, they give up and pass me to a "human," but that doesn't always work. I shutter to think of how many call center jobs have been lost to AI, and these people are some of the ones that need jobs the most and are now on the unemployment line triying to figure out what to do next, because what they know (i.e. customer service) is now all being done by AI unless you are a subject matter expert.

    3. Kathryn Diane Taft's Avatar Kathryn Diane Taft

      Never mind the ai, LOOK AT WHAT WE ARE ALLOWING TO HAPPEN TO OUR COUNTRY! The principles this country were founded on are what make us the greatest country in the world. We are all just watching it crumble down around us and doing NOTHING. Shop, shop, shop, watch our nation falling like it's a crime drama on tv, go online, complain, do nothing. Why aren't you at your capitol building right now DEMANDING that that pos exits the white house RIGHT NOW!!! Doesn't matter; Dem or Rep, that man is a rapist, a pedophile, and just a criminal. WTF, man? I walk my talk. Proud to be a TAFT woman, too bad I'm not a man, i'd be president.(i dont vote for women, ever.) Soooo not sorry

      1. Brian Hand's Avatar Brian Hand

        Please stop. You need help for your TDS.

        1. Michael Hunt's Avatar Michael Hunt

          "Trump Derangement Syndrome" isn't real, it's an accusation Trump supporters use to deflect and dismiss and criticism of the president, regardless of the validity of the criticism.

      2. Sir Lionheart's Avatar Sir Lionheart

        The beauty of America is that we have the freedom to disagree politically without resorting to inflammatory rhetoric and unsubstantiated accusations.

        You are certainly entitled to your opinion, Kathryn, but declaring that the country is crumbling doesn’t make it so, and demanding that a democratically elected president leave office simply because you despise him isn’t how democracy works. Presidents are elected under a constitutional process and, if necessary, removed through the constitutional process.

        I happen to believe President Trump is doing an excellent job, although I recognise that reasonable people can disagree about his policies and performance. What I would ask is that we judge his presidency on demonstrable evidence, actual policies, and measurable results rather than emotional declarations and personal hostility.

        Serious accusations, particularly criminal ones, deserve serious evidence rather than being thrown around as political insults.

        And there’s an interesting contradiction in your closing statement: you champion American principles while declaring that you never vote for women. Surely the principle of judging candidates on their merits, rather than their sex, is a far better reflection of the equality and individual freedom America aspires to uphold.

        You have every right to your opinion, just as the rest of us have the right to disagree with it. That’s democracy, not its destruction.

        🦁❤️

        1. Patricia Ann Gross's Avatar Patricia Ann Gross

          Sir LH,

          How about 34 Felony convictions? Demonstrable enough? How about late night rants on Truth Social that make little common sense or else are incompatible with human decency (calling names, etc.)? Falling asleep during Cabinet meetings? How much are you paying now for gas (oh, I forgot, you blame that one on Gavin Newsome)? Have you received your DOGE refund yet? How about your tariff rebate? I don't know about you but with the way inflation is going, that $7,000 would disappear in just about three months. When they do come through, do you think they will pay interest on them? He is now "considering" pardons in advance of the mid-terms, which are likely to demolish the stranglehold Republicans have on Congress, to protect his "buddies" like Musk who are targets for investigations for corruption. Tell me, if there wasn't corruption, why would they need pardons? By the way, that stranglehold by the Republicans bypasses the constitutional ability to remove the President because they need a 2/3 vote to impeach, and not a single Republican has the nerve to go against him. He is also floating the the idea that he will veto any bill that crosses his desk in the next two years that is either democrat sponsored or bipartisan, leaving the same 2/3 vote issue to overturn the veto. He'll wear out an autopen just vetoing bills. I could go on, but I will stop there.

          1. Sir Lionheart's Avatar Sir Lionheart

            You certainly have a long list of grievances, but listing everything you dislike about a president doesn’t necessarily establish that his presidency is a failure.

            I don’t dispute his convictions for falsifying business records. However, voters are entitled to consider the circumstances, the legal proceedings, and the eventual outcome when forming their opinions. A conviction is a fact, but it doesn’t automatically settle the question of someone’s ability to govern.

            As for Truth Social posts, name-calling, falling asleep in meetings and personal behaviour, you’re entitled to dislike them. I don’t particularly enjoy political mudslinging either. But I’d rather judge a presidency primarily on its policies, achievements and measurable results over a full term and not just 2 years in, than on social media commentary.

            On gas prices and inflation, let’s remember that economic conditions are influenced by numerous domestic and international factors. Presidents have considerable influence, but they don’t control every economic variable. I’m quite happy to scrutinize the administration’s economic performance, just as I would any other administration at the end of his term.

            Regarding pardons, I agree that the prospect of pre-emptively pardoning political allies deserves scrutiny. But a pardon isn’t proof of guilt, just as the possibility of an investigation isn’t proof of corruption.

            One point I’d correct is your constitutional argument. The House impeaches a president by a simple majority. It takes a two-thirds majority in the Senate to convict and remove him. You’re possibly confusing two separate stages of the process.

            Ultimately, I support our President because I believe his policies and direction are beneficial to America. That doesn’t mean I agree with everything he says or does, or that I consider him infallible.

            You are perfectly entitled to oppose him, just as I am entitled to support him. But surely the sensible way to debate his presidency is to examine the evidence on both sides rather than assume that anyone who supports him is somehow blind to reality.

            A DOGE refund isn't an established entitlement or guaranteed payment.

            As for the Auto pen, you just might be thinking of the wrong President. 😜

            Disagreement is democracy. Demanding that everyone shares your political conclusions isn’t, but ultimately the final opinions are left to us all at the next General Election in 2 years.

            🦁❤️

            1. Patricia Ann Gross's Avatar Patricia Ann Gross

              Sir LH,

              Nice catch on my misstep. Rather than impeach, I should have said remove him, which would be the result of a(nother) conviction. He has also been impeached twice, once for an insurrection (which you probably support). You go on believing he is the savior of the world, even though most of the rest of the world disagrees. It's no skin off my nose. If he were ever to be on a ballot again in an election we both vote in, we would probably cancel out each other's votes. Ain't democracy great???? Let's all hope (and since I know you don't pray, but I will) that we all survive the next two years.

              Thank you for acknowledging—and not defending—his more troubling attributes. The fact that you would support someone with 34 felony convictions, which would likely disqualify anyone from running an organization with a multi-trillion-dollar budget, when most U.S. companies would not tolerate such a record, speaks volumes. I highly doubt he would hire himself to manage one of his own companies under these circumstances. But then again, here we are.

              1. Sir Lionheart's Avatar Sir Lionheart

                I appreciate your acknowledgement of the impeachment distinction. And yes, Trump was impeached twice, but it’s worth remembering that the Senate acquitted him on both occasions. The second impeachment concerned the charge of incitement of insurrection, but it did not result in a Senate conviction. Those are the constitutional facts.

                I haven’t suggested Trump is the saviour of the world. That’s your interpretation, not my position, though it is comical. I simply believe his policies and leadership are taking America in a direction I support. There is a considerable difference between supporting a president and believing he’s infallible.

                Your comparison with corporate employment is interesting, but running a private company and being elected president are fundamentally different things. Ultimately, the American electorate decides who occupies the White House, subject to the Constitution and the law.

                And yes, democracy is great! It means people can vote against Donald Trump, and people like myself can vote for him. Neither of us has to apologize for exercising that right.

                I suspect we won’t change each other’s minds, and that’s perfectly fine. I would much rather have a civil intelligent disagreement than expect everyone to see the world through the same political lens.

                I enjoy the conversation, and let’s all hope, liberals and conservatives, that the next two years are good for America, regardless of our political differences.

                🦁❤️

              2. Patricia Ann Gross's Avatar Patricia Ann Gross

                Sir LH,

                You and I are two that understand that running a company and running a government, especially a democrachy are two fundamentally different things. Unfortunately, if you put the two of us into a room with the entire executive branch and 3/4 of the MAGA Republicans, we may be the only ones in the room that understand that distinction. Sad reality: A business is a dictatorship where the CEO is the King/Dictator, the US Federal Government is a Constitutional Republic, and there are safeguards and a balance of power that has to be recognized and upheld. His understanding of being President as the "King of the World" started with a Day One flurry of Executive orders that ended up with a large number being struck down in the courts because they were not decisions he could make without Congressional approval. The EO pen has not quit despite his encounters with being struck down by the courts. Even though he has had the majority of the Senate that can block anything the House comes up with (which was why his impeachments, by the way, never ended in a conviction and the same happened with Clinton as well if you remember back that far) he chose to act independently rather than going through the constitutionally defined process. My only explanation for that decision was that he did not want to share credit with congress, which would have been a better legacy than what he will end up with now. Even if the House and Senate flip after today's election, the democrats will likely not have the power to convict an impeachment or override a veto with a 2/3 vote, unless a bunch of Republicans cross the aisle. I'm not sure I would want him impeached or Amendment 25 invoked anyway, because most of those who are in the line of succession are scarier than he is.

      3. ServantOfJudgement's Avatar ServantOfJudgement

        My friend Kathryn, we did protest. We protested and elected Mr Trump as president. Not one gas station was burned, not one jewelry shop was looted and not one brick was thrown. We protested properly.

        Thank God for President Trump and surprisingly, thank God for the vile democratic politicians that made President Trump electable.

        1. Michael Hunt's Avatar Michael Hunt

          Did you forget about January 6? How about the plan to kidnap Gretchen Whitmer? Remember the Brooks Brothers Riots in 2000?

          Also, protesting the murder of people of color by law enforcement is not the same as protesting the results of an election that was clearly free and fair, despite the loser's claims. The overwhelming majority of the protests in the wake of George Floyd's murder were peaceful but the right will only focus on the few that dissolved into violence.

          Lets be very clear though, I understand how seeing people who look like you get murdered by the people who are supposed to "serve and protect" your community could cause the level of anger, fear, and desperation to lead a person to responding violently. I don't understand why people would storm the capital and chant, "hang Mike Pence" while stalking the halls and trashing offices just because a habitual liar blatantly lied that he won a presidential election that he clearly lost. These two things are not the same.

Leave a Comment

When leaving your comment, please:

  • Be respectful and constructive
  • Criticize ideas, not people
  • Avoid profanity, insults, and derogatory comments

To view the full code of conduct governing these comment sections, please visit this page.

Not ordained yet? Hit the button below to get started. Once ordained, log in to your account to leave a comment!
Don't have an account yet? Create Account